Leading the EU from Below

Finally, some praise for the EU’s choice of President and Foreign Minister of the EU.  The New York Times article on The EU’s New Leaders acknowledges that the choice of a Haiku-writing Belgian Prime Minister and a British baroness and EU Trade Commissioner was smart.

Why so smart? Well, because governance of a network cannot be based on pure hierarchical principles. For starters, because there is no clear hierarchy. Everything is alliances, soft power, give and take, symbolic gestures and horse trading.  Secondly, because hierarchy is not wanted. The EU is composed of 27 Member States each with their own idea of leadership. What they want is a negotiator, someone who can make the most of a near impossible situation.

Needless to say, this does not mean that top-down power will not be involved. The wonderfully strange thing about even such a surprising appointment is that it becomes power. In that sense, leadership from below is a very precarious state of affairs. It seldom happens, or rather, it happens quite often, but once it is recognized as such, it ceases to exist. Plain old leadership takes over. The disciple becomes the leader.

Another thing is that to Belgians, of course, the notion of their Prime Minister being an unknown figure is hard to fathom. This is another very interesting facet of leadership. It can actually be very local. Nobody is felt as more powerful than a tribal leader in a small community. Yet, his or her power seldom extends beyond a few hundred people and beyond a small physical territory. But to the locals, this does not matter.

The challenge with the EU has always been that its actions are slow to seep down to individuals. Even though the European policy debates are much more consequential than national policy debates, they are less talked about. The sociology of the whole thing is relatively straight forward. Whatever people think is real becomes real in its consequences. People refuse to believe that an organizational structure they do not understand and politicians and bureaucrats they do not know can have any power at all over themselves. However, if you have seen someone on TV, shaken their hand in a parade, and they talk about your top ten concerns (taxes, the economy, social benefits, safety, culture etc.), then you believe they really can affect change. Little do we consider the fact that politicians may well talk of things they cannot really deliver…

So, in a situation where the national scene is where heroes and villains are created, there is little scope for big Europe. And maybe that is the price we have to pay for real progress on policy issues.

The next few years will show whether this strategy works. I, for one, think that there is much to gain by testing the waters of networked leadership. The EU is the best example we have. The laboratory is a bunch of very much alive Europeans who are slowly recovering from a financial crisis. So, the stakes are high, but the results could be good, if not great. Not bad at all.


About trondau
Trond A. Undheim (39), Ph.D., a Senior Lecturer at MIT Sloan School of Management, and Managing Director of Tautec Consulting, has over fifteen years of multi sector experience in strategy, policy, communications, academia, and entrepreneurship. Formerly, he was a Director of Standards Strategy and Policy at Oracle Corporation, with wide responsibilities in long-term business development, strategy, public policy and standardization globally and in Europe. Trond is an executive, speaker, entrepreneur, author, traveler and blogger. With a doctorate on knowledge work and the internet in Silicon Valley, he is one of the world’s leading experts on technology and society. He has worked at Oracle Corporation, the European Commission, the Norwegian Government, and founded a start-up. He was awarded an interdisciplinary Ph.D. from NTNU, Norway’s top engineering university, as the youngest candidate at the Faculty. He is multilingual and has lived on three continents. He is always ready for strategic opportunities providing significant intellectual and managerial challenges.

One Response to Leading the EU from Below

  1. bixinjemi says:

    I really enjoyed reading this post, keep up creating such interesting posts!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: